How Ziegler & Cole signed the cases it used to lose to voicemail.
For years, the after-hours wreck calls went to a machine and the caller went to the next firm. Then a Friday-night pileup on the I-90/I-94 sent nine injured callers to a dark office. Sarah, live for two weeks, signed the consults nobody was there to take.
“Nine calls came in after we'd gone home. The old me would've gotten two of them on Monday.”Rachel Ziegler · 11:52 PM, Friday
Six metrics, year over year.
Pulled from the business's CRM exports and Sarah's call logs: the twelve months before signup, against the twelve months on Ansa.
Where they were, what they did, what's true now.
- 01Where they were
Four attorneys, Chicago PI clicks at about $150 each, and a phone that stopped at six. When a wreck happened at midnight (which is when wrecks happen), the call went to voicemail and the caller went to the next firm. About a quarter of PI intent arrives after hours, and Ziegler & Cole was catching none of it.
- 02What they did
April 2026. Rachel ran the ad-spend audit and saw the math: ~$1,500 to acquire a signed case, ~$16k in fees per case, and a stack of after-hours calls that never got returned before the caller signed elsewhere. She signed up and was live in two weeks, just before the Friday pileup that proved the point.
- 03What's true now
Sarah answers every intake call in seconds, day or night, captures the incident and injuries, runs the conflict name before booking, and pages the on-call attorney with the file. She doesn't give legal advice; she does intake. But the firm hasn't lost an after-hours case to a competitor's faster pickup since signup.
In personal injury the case goes to whoever answers the phone, not whoever has the best billboard. We were buying the click for a hundred and fifty dollars and then losing the call to a machine. Sarah is the reason we're first now, and I'm not paying an attorney to sit by the phone at 1 AM to do it.
Ziegler & Cole is typical, not exceptional.
Most PI firms on Ansa land in the same range: after-hours intake going from zero to caught, every call conflict-checked, payback inside the first signed case. Here's where Ziegler & Cole sits against the rest of our law-firm customers.
Shops like this one, different story.
You just read someone else’s call. Take one of your own.
Put your number in and she calls you back as your business, with your hours and your services. Then you have your own version of the story above.
Would rather price it out first? Get started